WCAG 1.3.3 means an instruction cannot lean only on shape, color, size, visual location, orientation or sound, so "press the round button on the right" needs the button's name too. The rule is Level A, and fixing it is mostly a writing job rather than a coding one.
We cover the traits WCAG names, who benefits, markup before and after, copy rewrites, a review routine and the rules that sit close to this one. For the full list of rules at each level, use our WCAG checklist.
Quick facts
Level
AAdded in
WCAG 2.0Principle
Perceivable, guideline 1.3 AdaptableTraits named
Shape, color, size, visual location, orientation, soundFix
Name the control or item in words as wellFast test
Search your copy for left, right, round, red, green, beep
"Press the green button on the right"
That sentence is easy for a sighted user with full color vision on a wide screen. Now try it as a blind screen reader user, who hears no colors and no positions. Try it as a person with red and green color blindness. Try it on a phone, where "on the right" has become "somewhere further down". Each of them is stuck, and the instruction is the problem, not the button.
This is the situation the rule targets: guidance that only makes sense if you can see or hear a particular quality of the page.
What WCAG 1.3.3 actually requires
Instructions for understanding or operating content must not depend only on sensory characteristics. WCAG names them: "shape, color, size, visual location, orientation, or sound" (WCAG 2.2, 1.3.3). You may still mention them. The rule is about the word only. Add something that does not need eyes or ears, which in practice is almost always the visible name of the thing.
| Trait | Risky wording | Safer wording |
|---|---|---|
| Shape | Select the round icon | Select the Help button (the round icon) |
| Color | Fields in red are required | Fields marked Required must be filled in |
| Size | Use the big button to continue | Select Continue |
| Visual location | See the box on the right | See the Delivery options box |
| Orientation | Use the vertical menu | Use the Account menu |
| Sound | Answer when you hear the beep | Answer when the timer shows Start and the beep plays |
Who relies on non-sensory instructions
- Blind and low vision users cannot use color, shape or layout cues, and screen magnifier users view a sliver of the screen at a time.
- Color blind visitors often confuse red with green, or orange with brown.
- Deaf and hard of hearing users miss audio prompts such as chimes and spoken cues.
- Phone users and anyone zoomed in see a stacked layout where left and right no longer exist; reflow explains why that layout is required.
- People with cognitive disabilities often find a named target easier than a described one.
Before and after in the markup
Fails: the hint relies on shape and position, and the button has no visible text to match.
<p>To save your draft, use the round icon at the top right.</p>
<button type="button" class="icon-round">
<svg aria-hidden="true" viewBox="0 0 24 24"><path d="M5 3h14v18H5z"/></svg>
</button>Passes: the hint names the control, and the control shows that same word.
<p>To save your draft, select Save draft.</p>
<button type="button" class="icon-round">
<svg aria-hidden="true" viewBox="0 0 24 24"><path d="M5 3h14v18H5z"/></svg>
Save draft
</button>The visible word also helps voice control users, who can say "click Save draft". Matching the visible label with the accessible name is a separate rule; see label in name.
Copy patterns that fail, and rewrites
| Found in | Failing text | Fix |
|---|---|---|
| Form hint | Required fields are shown in red | Add the word Required to each label, and keep the red if you like |
| Help text | Use the menu on the left to change settings | Open the Settings menu |
| Quiz | Drag the square shapes into the box | Name each item and the target box, and offer a keyboard option |
| Error message | Fix the fields with a red border | List the fields by name with what is wrong |
| Video or game | Wait for the sound, then press start | Show a visual cue at the same moment as the sound |
| Onboarding tour | Tap the star icon below | Tap Favourites (the star icon) |
Words like "above" and "below" are often fine when they also match the reading order, because a screen reader user meets the item before or after the instruction too. "See the table below" passes when the table really comes next in the code.
A 1.3.3 wcag review in six steps
Automated checkers cannot read the meaning of your copy, so this check is manual. Content editors can do it as well as developers.
- Collect the instructions. Gather every piece of text that tells people how to use the page: form hints, help text, error messages, onboarding tips, video scripts and chatbot replies.
- Search for sensory words. Look for left, right, top, bottom, beside, round, square, big, small, red, green, color names, icon names, beep, chime and tone.
- Ask the blindfold question. For each match, ask whether someone who cannot see or hear the page could still follow the instruction from the words alone.
- Check the named control exists in text. If an instruction names a button, confirm the button has that same visible text or accessible name.
- Zoom and narrow the page. View the page at 400 percent zoom or phone width and see whether positional words like "on the right" are still true.
- Play any sound cues muted. Turn the sound off and confirm every audio alert, such as a timer chime, also shows a text message.
Neighbouring rules: color, structure and orientation
Color shows up in two rules, which confuses many teams. 1.4.1 covers color used as the only way to show information, such as a red border marking an error. 1.3.3 covers instructions that point to color. A form with red required fields and the hint "red fields are required" fails both. Read the use of color guide for the visual side.
1.3.4 Orientation is unrelated despite the shared word: it is about not locking a page to a single screen orientation. 1.3.1 deals with structure in code, which you can review in our structure page.
The W3C notes and examples for this criterion are on the Understanding Sensory Characteristics page.
Questions people ask
What does 1.3.3 wcag mean in one sentence?
Instructions must not rely only on how something looks, where it sits or how it sounds. Give its name or label as well, so people who cannot see or hear that quality can still follow along.
What level is sensory characteristics?
Level A. It came in with WCAG 2.0, and the current wording lists color among the traits. Every A and AA audit covers it.
Can I still say "the button on the right"?
Yes, as long as you also name the button, such as "select Next, on the right". The positional hint then helps sighted users while the name works for everyone.
Are icons without text a 1.3.3 failure?
The icon on its own is a 1.1.1 or 4.1.2 issue if it has no name. It becomes a 1.3.3 failure when the instructions refer to the icon only by its shape, such as "tap the gear".
Does an audio beep in a timer fail 1.3.3?
It fails if the beep is the only signal people are told to wait for. Show a visible message or change at the same moment so deaf users get the same cue.